I'm rechristening Tech "Blog Fodder" because that is clearly his role in my life.
Episode 1: So close.
Jekyll: We're going to dilute this antibody 1:1000. That is, one part antibody per one thousand parts total solution. So if we want a final volume of 1 mL, ie 1000 microliters, how much antibody should we add?
BF: Um, one microliter?
Jekyll: [relieved] Yes! That's right. Now we want to make a 1:2000 dilution, again with a final volume of 1 mL. How much antibody do we need?
BF: Uh, 0.2 microliter?
Episode 2: Do as I say, not as you think.
Jekyll: While I'm gone at journal club, add 0.2 mL of this solution to each well of the 24-well plate. There will be leftover solution, but don't throw it out because we'll use it later.
BF: Ok.
[1 hour elapses]
Jekyll: I'm back. Hey, how come there's such a large volume in these wells?
BF: Well, there was a lot of leftover solution, so I just added it all to the wells so as not to waste it.
Episode 3: OH REALLY?
Jekyll: Doing all these molarity and concentration calculations is going to be really important, and I think it would be good if you practiced them. Here are a few websites that have tutorials on how to calculate these things. You should review them and do the practice problems. Later this week I'll try to find a chem textbook so you can go over the material on solutions.
BF: Yeah, I guess you found my weak spot in math!
Jekyll: That's ok, molarity and concentrations just take some practice.
BF: It's been a long time since my last chemistry class.
Jekyll: Oh? What did you major in--psychology?
BF: Neurobiology. I took chem as a freshman and then orgo as a sophomore, but that was over two years ago so I'm rusty.
Jekyll: Hm, what lab classes did you take?
BF: Well, none in bio.
Jekyll: What?
BF: The lab classes were only required for pre-meds, and I wasn't pre-med. I want to go to graduate school.
Let me help you out with that decision, young man. You should not even go near heavy machinery, let alone graduate school.
Gaaah. Advisor has been away for a few days but he will want a report on BF when he returns. I plan on telling the truth. Advisor will undoubtedly ask me if we should fire him. I have to make a decision.
OTOH, if you watch like a hawk, BF can do what he's told. He is indeed improving his hand steadiness by means of forearm support etc. And we really just need a tech for menial tasks that do not involve much thinking. If he can conquer molarity, he should be fine.
OTOH, why does anybody with two university-level chem classes and a B.S. in neurobiology still need to conquer molarity?
15 years ago
16 comments:
No lab classes in biology?! Holy crap. I transferred from a (pretty awesome) community college to a large state university and I've been making fun of their puny lab requirements ever since. Even so, any biology major here requires the equivalent of three classes with at least three hours a week of lab.
Episode 2 really threw me for a loop.
Um, why was this dude hired in the first place? Are there some redeeming features you're not mentioning? Because he sounds pretty pathetic...
Yeah, episode 2 was ridiculous. That's got nothing to do with science, but more to do with listening and following directions.
As for no lab classes, WTF?
Hopefully this guy really can be trained to do some stuff, and if he does, I hope he stays for long enough duration to actually be useful.
He's definitely giving you stuff to blog about. Wow, neurobiology? I would have never guessed. And who steers potential grad students AWAY from laboratories? (Unless it was advising specific to this guy....)
I'd recommend firing him. I don't understand how this guy was hired in the first place.
Well, none of these failures was quite so obvious in the interview (although I found him rather unresponsive even then...).
And I have to admit that prior to hiring him, our discussion ran something like, "Hey, all we need is someone to pipette and make buffers and stuff, so an Ivy League grad with a bio degree ought to be safe."
HAHAHAHAHA.
I think he may have been exempt from labs by teching in a "real" lab during his undergrad years? But I'm not sure how that could be the case and him still be so ignorant. Maybe it was a psych lab with no buffers?
Yeah, I'm with grad student. Frankly, without extenuating circumstances that you're not aware of (he's actual your PI's nephew, etc), the things you're explaining are remarkable. It's one thing to not know what you're doing (Lord knows I was a freakin' moron when I first started as a full time tech at Fancy Pants Institute), but he doesn't seem to be making a good faith effort to understand what you're teaching or even f'ing listen to your directions. You can find an undergrad who can make lab solutions.
Keep the Episodes coming. Your BF is fast becoming my BFF for the entertainment he provides.
Jekyll: Oh? What did you major in--psychology?
Bigot.
Jekyll: Oh? What did you major in--psychology?
Bigot.
Um, what he really needs to learn is HOW TO FOLLOW THE BLOODY DIRECTIONS. For real.
Ivy League? Ha ha ha. HA.
I'm totally with DamnGoodTechnician said...
It doesn't seem like your BF cares about what you are saying.
And if he does such stupid mistakes who knows what an epic screw up he can produce later.
I had smart undergrads who nonetheless used some precisious reagents in milliliters instead of microliters, placed sensitive samples into wrong refrigerators (-70 instead of +4) or mixed reagents hours before they start actual kinetic measurements.
It's just about damage control...
No bio labs for someone planning on going to grad school in bio!? That's madness. I can understand that most universities don't have the facilities to let undergraduate students try some of the awesome and fun techniques I've gotten to do, but no labs at all? Not even as part of a non-lab course?
I'm in a neuroscience program and not only do I have to take a million courses with lab components, but I also a have to take lab course covering some of the basics in neurobiology. I am so thankful that my univesity is somewhat sane and makes us do this stuff.
This dude is a Dumb Fuck Forever (h/t Professor in Training), and needs to be fired immediately.
When I started in my first grad school lab rotation, I frequently messed up molarity calculations (though not the easy easy ones as you mentioned here). This embarrassed me IMMENSELY bc I have EXTENSIVE lab experience as an undergrad. I went to a SLAC but by my last year there, my mentor was confident enough to leave the lab in my care while he took a 6-month sabbatical. So I must have known something.
I think that the reason I balls up so bad during my first week of grad school was that I was assigned to work under a sociopathic post-doc (not implying that you are one of these) who took pleasure in going "tick-tock, tick-tock" while I scribbled out the calculations...and then loudly mocked me so that the whole lab could hear when I got it wrong. I didn't end up joining that lab.
That being said, it only took me about a week to get my nerves under control around this woman and I did my best to give her as little fodder as possible.
If that were it I think your BF would be redeemable. But the lack of lab experience for someone who wants to go from Ivy to grad school raises a lot of red flags.
And the whole attitude toward animals makes me think: OFF WITH HIS HEAD!!
By the way, I hope you won't mind that I've added a link to your blog over at mine http://ambivalentacademic.blogspot.com
Oh bikemonkey, all I meant by it was that psych majors aren't required to take chem and therefore might be excused from *necessarily* knowing how to do molarity calculations.
Besides, after I post today's episode it will be clear that even a psych department wouldn't want this boy genius. hahahaha!
Post a Comment